At the European Telework Online website - http://www.eto.org.uk
GAT (General Access - Telework) Chain
Chain Workplan for Telework Guidelines
Please address comments on this Workplan to Christian
Van Asbroeck, ETD Project, Chain Secretariat. The workplan has been
updated 28 October 1996 in the light of comments received and further guidance
provided at the GA Chains meeting on 23 October 1996.
This and all GAT documents are online at http://www.eto.org.uk/gat/.
Anyone who wishes to be kept informed of activities and outputs of the Telework
Chain can join an email information list, details are at http://www.eto.org.uk/gat/info.htm
Requirements and Priorities
The Commission's guidance document dated 4 September 1996 identifies three
main constituencies of interest within which consensus on Guidelines needs
to be sought:
- the technology development constituency
- the social/industrial and political constituencies
- the independent teleworkers and networked SMEs constituencies
Although in principle any significant Guideline needs to be widely endorsed
across all constituencies, the main interest in a particular Guideline will
come from the constituencies that feel most closely associated with that
Guideline. The GAT Chain needs to engage the attention of all three groups,
so we propose that our priority for the creation of draft Guidelines should
be to produce at least one Guideline focused on a topic of interest to each
of the three groups. As an example we might aim to produce:
- a Guideline focused on interoperability, of interest to all three
groups, but based on the perception of the topic, of primary interest to
the technology development constituency;
- a Guideline focused on access to telework opportunities by the self
employed and micro-enterprises, of primary interest to the independent teleworkers
and networked SMEs constituencies but also of increasing interest to the
social/industrial and political constituencies, given the perception that
small firms are the main dependency for future employment creation and economic
success;
- a Guideline focused on the role and impact of telework in the processes
of job creation and job destruction, which will be of primary interest to
the social/industrial and political constituencies.
Suggestions for alternative
or additional priority topics for Guidelines are welcome please.
The current list of "Guidelines in progress" can be seen at http://www.eto.org.uk/gat/index.htm.
Creation of Draft Guidelines
Two templates for draft Guidelines have been developed and are online at:
- Template
1 - http://www.eto.org.uk/gat/guides/templ1.htm
- For a "bottom up" approach, staring from a discussion of
the requirements and focusing in on a Guideline through comment and discussion;
- Template
2 - http://www.eto.org.uk/gat/guides/templ1.htm
- For a "top down" approach, starting from a Provisional Guideline
and refining this through challenge and discussion, which will also elicit
rationale and supporting materials.
As a test of the Commission's expectations, two drafts have been created
by the ETD project and are also online:
- Telework: Interoperability Guidelines - online at
http://www.eto.org.uk/gat/guid
es/gat-g1.htm
- This has been produced using the bottom up approach.
- Telework: Access to Work Opportunities for Self Employed,
Micro-Enterprises and Virtual Enterprises - online at http://www.eto.org.uk/gat/guid
es/gat-g2.htm
- Produced using the top down approach
We have asked for comments from Commission Services on these two drafts
and hope to have received some comments before or during the Chain meeting
in Vienna on 4th November, so that future work of the Chain can be appropriately
focused.
Our current perception is that the best way to proceed with Guidelines is
as follows:
- A project proposes a particular Guideline topic and declares its intention
of supporting the development process for that Guideline (the "owning
project"). Any ACTS project participating in the ACTS Telework Chain
may propose a Guidelines topic. Support to the development process entails
provision of an initial draft and an editor - see below.
- An individual (nominated by the proposing project) creates an initial
draft and assumes ownership of the comments and editing processes (the editor).
- The initial draft is placed online at a www site accessible by the
editor, and is indexed along with all Telework
Guidelines at the ETD website. The draft may be online at the owning project's
site or at the ETD site.
- A mechanism is provided on the www for making comments on the draft
- by comments is included suggested additions, rewordings, deletions etc;
comments should be constructive only please. Where possible comments should
take the form of proposed additional or alternative wordings. Comments should
be accompanied by the name of the person making the comment and their affiliation.
The online mechanism will be provided by the ETD project unless the owning
project is able to resource its own equivalent mechanism.
- All comments will be visible to active participants in the Chain.
- At a suitable stage (usually no later than a date announced in advance)
the editor will re-draft the Guideline, taking into account comments received
by that date. At least two weeks notice will be given of the closing date
for comments. The mechanism for this will be the GAT
notices email list.
- At this point a decision will be made by the Telework Chain Chair
as to whether the present draft is sufficiently advanced to be reviewed
externally, so as to start the process of achieving consensus with relevant
constituencies.
- The main method for external review and comment will be the same as
that for internal Chain review, namely comments by email displayed at the
website; however in order to obtain comments that properly represent informed
opinion in the constituencies most concerned it may be necessary to circulate
paper versions and provide a paper mechanism for obtaining comments - the
(ETD) Chain Secretariat will handle this, unless the Guideline is one within
the scope of the DIPLOMAT project's outreach activities. Other GAT projects
may also take on this role or participate, for example EPRIWATCH may provide
mechanisms for comments from the European political constituences, FAIR
from the economic analysis constituencies. All Chain projects should endeavour
to make the Guideline known to as wide a relevant audience as possible.
A forms-based process will be made available for the collection of formal
comments.
- Either the ETD Secretariat or the appropriate project will monitor
and assess the scope of interests represented among the comments received
so as to determine when a wide enough range of comment has been received.
- When in the view of the Chain Chair a sufficiency of external comment
has been received the editor will again re-draft the Guideline, which will
then be made available to all concerned as a final draft
As stated in the Commission's guidance, it will be for the Commission to
determine whether, and if so, when to adopt and publish any Guideline as
a Commission supported statement on the relevant issues and policies. All
versions published by the Telework Chain will therefore carry the statement:
- This draft Guideline is produced and made available for general
information and comment by a group of projects working together in the ACTS
Programme Telework Chain; all statements contained in the draft Guideline
are the responsibility of the editor/project (see note) named in the Guideline
and do not represent an official policy statement of either the companies
participating in the projects concerned or of the European Commission. Comments
should please be sent to (email and other coordinates of the editor).
The ETD Initiative can provide all necessary www facilities for those editors/projects
not wishing to host the Guidelines process at their own sites, and can provide
a pseudo email address for editors who wish comments to be batched and displayed
rather than receiving them as personal mail.
Languages
The language for the work of the Chain is English. The Chain Secretariat
cannot resource the additional effort and cost of providing translations
of Draft Guidelines. Projects are encouraged where possible to make translations
availble in other national languages. To the extent that constituencies
of interest may not have a wide enough opportunity to review a Guideline
if it is available in English only, and the owning project cannot resource
necessary translation, the matter will be refered to the Commission for
comment.
IPR
The IPR in any draft or completed Guideline resides in the Chain as a whole
and all draft Guidelines should be freely available for reproduction, dissemination
etc. Where useful background information is relevant to a Guideline this
should not be included in the main text but should be cited and referenced,
preferably providing an online reference. IPR in all such background material
remains with the existing owner.
Testing the Process
As a test for this process the ETD Initiative has produced an initial draft,
Telework: Interoperability Guidelines, as agreed at the GAT Chain
27th June meeting in Luxembourg, and a further draft Telework: Access
to Work Opportunities for Self Employed, Micro-Enterprises and Virtual Enterprises.
We ask that all projects associated with the GAT Telework Chain should please
nominate someone to comment on each of these drafts (not necessarily the
same person for each) and that following the Chain meeting in Vienna on
4 November 1996, efforts should be made by all these reviewers to post at
least one comment on the content of each draft within three weeks
of the meeting, ie by 25 November 1996. The ETD Secretariat will then review
the comments received and discuss the situation with Commission Services,
with a view to producing during December at least one draft Guideline that
is of an acceptable standard for the Chain to use as a baseline for future
work. We ask that reviewers and others please refrain from commenting
on the format and structure of the drafts as we need to review these with
Commission Services and will provide further guidance on this aspect as
we learn from that process.
This Workplan document was last
updated: 30 October 1996
Page address of this Guideline: http://www.eto.org.uk/gat/guides/wplan01.htm
Chain participants may comment on this workplan by emailing etd-gat-wplan01@eto.org.uk.
Previous comments can be seen at http://www.eto.org.uk/gat/guides/wp01-mail.
The ACTS Telework Chain (GAT) pages are hosted at the European Telework
Online website - http://www.eto.org.uk
Return to index of GAT ACTS Telework
Chain Guidelines
General information about the GAT ACTS Telework Chain